When selecting roofing shingles, homeowners often compare popular brands like Malarkey and Owens Corning. Each has distinct features and styles, with varying strengths. This article will highlight the differences between the two, assisting you in determining which shingles may suit your home best. Whether you prioritize durability, energy efficiency, or aesthetic appeal, there are several factors beyond brand reputation to think about. Let’s take a closer look at what each brand provides!
Overview of Malarkey Shingles
Malarkey shingles are known for their durability and special features, including upcycled rubber content, which improves impact resistance during hailstorms. This material helps them endure harsh conditions, making them suitable for different climates. When looking at warranties, Malarkey offers a limited lifetime warranty, indicating trust in their product’s longevity, often exceeding that of lower-quality options.
Homeowners appreciate roofing materials like dimensional shingles, which mimic wood shake and slate tile, providing homes with a stylish appearance while enhancing wind resistance. Regarding design options, Malarkey shingles offer a variety of color choices that allow homeowners to elevate their house’s exterior. Their architectural shingles also consist of multiple layers that effectively seal the roof, improving insulation and ventilation.
This attention to both design and performance makes Malarkey a strong option for roof replacement projects, backed by the knowledge of contractors who understand local building codes and quality installation methods. These features together make Malarkey one of the top choices for home improvement.
Overview of Owens Corning Shingles
Owens Corning shingles are recognized in the roofing industry for their distinctive features. They come in various styles, such as laminated and architectural shingles, enhancing both durability and visual appeal. Constructed with a fiberglass base, these shingles offer impressive wind and impact resistance, making them suitable for severe weather conditions.
Their durability is supported by warranties that frequently include a limited lifetime guarantee, giving homeowners confidence during roof replacement.
Additionally, the shingles come in a wide array of color choices, enabling homeowners to beautifully match their home’s exterior. They are designed with a special seal that secures the shingles in place, improving their efficiency. This high-quality roofing material supports ventilation and insulation, complying with local building requirements and boosting energy efficiency. With competitive pricing, they deliver value while ensuring experience and quality assurance from trusted roofing companies. While some may argue that brands like Malarkey provide innovative features using upcycled rubber, appealing to sustainability-minded homeowners, Owens Corning’s long-standing reputation in roofing products remains a strong option for residential roofing needs.
Are Malarkey Shingles Better Than Owens Corning Shingles?
Malarkey shingles stand out due to their unique features, such as impact resistance and the use of upcycled rubber, which enhance durability against elements like hail. This specific material can increase a roof’s lifespan and offer superior protection compared to builder grade options. The warranties for Malarkey shingles often include a limited lifetime warranty, suggesting long-term coverage that some may find more appealing than the warranties offered with Owens Corning shingles.
When it comes to aesthetics, Malarkey provides a variety of color options in both laminated and architectural shingles that can resemble wood shake or slate tile. This versatility allows homeowners to match these shingles to their home exterior, offering a fresh look that might be more limited in Owens Corning’s lineup.
Additionally, Malarkey’s dimensional shingles may enhance the visual appeal of any house while maintaining high wind resistance. For a roof replacement, choosing shingles with impressive warranty coverage and attractive designs, like those from Malarkey, could be a wise decision for improving home value over time.
Comparison of Durability
Malarkey Shingles Durability Features
Malarkey shingles stand out due to their use of upcycled rubber blended with SBS modified asphalt, enhancing impact resistance and durability. This unique material helps these shingles resist damage from hail and other extreme weather conditions, making them an excellent choice for roofing needs. Compared to standard options like builder grade or 3-tab shingles, Malarkey offers superior wind resistance and extended life expectancy.
Homeowners can expect dimensional shingles that not only seal well but also come in a variety of color options to fit the house’s aesthetic.
Owens Corning Shingles Durability Features
Owens Corning shingles incorporate advanced technologies and materials that enhance their durability. Their architectural shingles often feature fiberglass base layers that provide strong support, while laminated shingles are designed for better wind and impact resistance. This means these roofing materials hold up well against harsh weather, including strong winds and hail.
Shingles like Northgate and Legacy include upcycled rubber for added impact strength, making them suitable for houses in hail-prone areas. The limited lifetime warranty offered for many of their shingles reinforces trust in their longevity and performance, reflecting a commitment to durable roofing. This warranty coverage often varies by product, indicating how manufacturers like Owens Corning support their roofing supply.
Homeowners appreciate the variety of color options and designs, from dimensional shingles to those resembling wood shake or slate tile, allowing them to enhance their home exterior while ensuring reliability. When choosing shingles, the experience and contractor status of the roofing company also influence the success of a roof replacement project.
Comparison of Aesthetics
Design Options for Malarkey Shingles
Malarkey shingles offer a variety of design options that enhance home exteriors. These shingles come in multiple styles, including dimensional shingles that replicate the appearance of wood shake or slate tile. The color options are extensive, making it easy for homeowners to coordinate their roofing with siding or other house features. Malarkey’s architectural shingles improve aesthetics and provide excellent durability and wind resistance.
Their unique textures and patterns distinguish them from standard builder-grade shingles, creating a more upscale look.
Additionally, the upcycled rubber material in products like the Legacy contributes to their impact resistance and long life expectancy, often providing warranty coverage that exceeds many competitors. When homeowners select Malarkey, they gain access to quality roofing materials that perform well during inspections while embracing personal style for any roofing replacement project. This design versatility allows homeowners to express their preferences and ensures adherence to local building codes.
Design Options for Owens Corning Shingles
When considering design options for various shingles, a wide array of color choices and textures can enhance a home’s exterior. Architectural shingles come in dimensional styles, capable of mimicking the look of wood shake or slate tile. These options cater to different architectural styles, making them suitable for a variety of houses. In terms of sustainability, certain designs incorporate materials like upcycled rubber, which improve impact resistance and longevity.
These features boost durability and give homeowners confidence during roof inspections and after hail storms. Warranties, such as a limited lifetime warranty, often accompany these shingles, providing assurance of quality.
Additionally, durability factors are important; some shingles, like the Northgate, are recognized for strong performance against wind resistance and impact. Homeowners value these choices for their compatibility with insulation and ventilation requirements while adhering to local building codes. With quality roofing materials, contractors ensure proper installation, making these design options a good fit for roof replacement projects within home improvement efforts.
Are Malarkey Shingles Better Than Owens Corning Shingles in Terms of Cost?
Initial purchase costs can vary when comparing Malarkey shingles and Owens Corning shingles. Malarkey offers a range of architectural shingles with pricing that may fluctuate based on features like durability and impact resistance. In contrast, Owens Corning shingles may be available at a lower upfront cost but often fall under builder grade options that lack long-lasting benefits.
For long-term maintenance and roof replacement, factors such as the lifespan of the roofing materials and additional labor costs during installation significantly influence overall expenses. Malarkey shingles often provide enhanced durability and warranties, which can result in savings over time. When examining warranty coverage, Malarkey typically includes a limited lifetime warranty and offers energy-efficient options, potentially lowering energy bills through reduced heating and cooling costs.
The materials used in Malarkey shingles, like upcycled rubber and fiberglass base, also improve insulation and impact resistance, often making them a more cost-effective choice in the long run, especially in climates prone to hail.
Best Asphalt Shingles for Different Climates
Homeowners should look for shingles with great insulation and reflectivity when selecting materials for areas with extreme heat or bright sunlight. Dimensional shingles, such as those made with upcycled rubber, can offer better durability and energy efficiency, making them a smart option. In humid and rainy climates, moisture-resistant properties are significant because they help reduce the risk of mold and increase the lifespan of the roofing.
For homes in regions prone to hurricanes or strongstorms, wind resistance ratings should be a primary consideration. Shingles with higher wind ratings, like architectural and impact-resistant options, provide better protection against severe weather, ensuring structural integrity. Home improvement projects should include a detailed roof inspection and consultation with a local roofing company that understands local building regulations and the best shingles available.
This is particularly important for warranties; many roofing materials offer warranty coverage that varies based on intended use and climate, assisting homeowners in making informed choices on roofing supplies for their new roof.
F-Wave Roof Comparison
F-Wave roofing products often outperform traditional asphalt shingles in terms of durability and longevity. Unlike 3-tab shingles that may last around 25 years, F-Wave options can provide a longer life expectancy with enhanced wind resistance and impact resistance, making them suitable for homes in hail-prone areas.
In aesthetics, F-Wave materials offer a range of designer shingles that mimic the look of wood shake or slate tile, giving homeowners stylish choices while maintaining energy efficiency. They also provide various color options, akin to what can be found with architectural shingles from both Malarkey and other brands. Considering cost-effectiveness, F-Wave solutions might initially have a higher price point compared to some builder-grade offerings, but their durability and limited lifetime warranty add long-term value that appeals to those seeking a solid investment for their home exterior.
Homeowners gain peace of mind knowing the materials comply with local building codesand that proper installation can enhance roof ventilation and insulation.
Top Roofing Shingle Brands
When homeowners explore different roofing shingles, they often notice variations in quality and performance. The best shingles are crafted from premium materials like fiberglass base and may include advanced features, such as impact resistance, helping to shield them from hail damage. For instance, some brands provide architectural shingles or designer shingles that mimic wood shake or slate tile.
These dimensional shingles generally have a longer lifespan and better wind resistance than 3-tab shingles, making them a favored option for new roof installations. Customer reviews significantly influence the reputation of these brands. Positive feedback can showcase how effectively roofing materials seal and safeguard homes, whereas negative reviews may bring attention to issues with durability or contractor quality. Homeowners should weigh pricing, warranty coverage, and the expertise of their chosen roofing company when selecting materials for their home exterior.
It is also important toensure that roofing layers comply with local building codes and that insulation and ventilation are sufficient for the roof’s expected lifespan. The Malarkey Legacy and CertainTeed Northgate are examples of shingles known for their strength and warranty, explaining why they may be preferred options for roof replacement.
Customer Reviews and Satisfaction
Customers often express higher satisfaction with Malarkey shingles compared to Owens Corning shingles. They appreciate the durability and impact resistance of Malarkey’s architectural shingles, like the Legacy model made from upcycled rubber, which improves performance against hail. In contrast, some reviews indicate that Owens Corning shingles might not perform well against these weather conditions, with mentions of their builder grade products falling short in wind resistance.
Customer feedback on both brands highlights warranty coverage; Malarkey typically offers a limited lifetime warranty, adding to their attractiveness. Insights from customers show that while Owens Corning has various color options and a fiberglass base for aesthetics, many homeowners find that Malarkey’s roofing materials better satisfy their needs for insulation and ventilation.
FAQ
What are the key differences between Malarkey shingles and Owens Corning shingles?
Malarkey shingles offer enhanced sustainability and a rubberized modified asphalt for better performance in extreme weather, while Owens Corning shingles feature a wider variety of colors and styles. Choose Malarkey for eco-friendliness or Owens Corning for design options.
How do the warranties compare between Malarkey and Owens Corning shingles?
Malarkey shingles typically offer a limited lifetime warranty, covering manufacturing defects for 50 years, while Owens Corning provides a limited lifetime warranty as well, but often with additional 10-20 year warranties on specific products. Check the warranty details for each product to choose the best fit for your needs.
Which brand offers better durability and weather resistance: Malarkey or Owens Corning?
Malarkey shingles generally offer superior durability and weather resistance, featuring their proprietary polymer-modified asphalt. For example, Malarkey’s Vista shingles are rated for higher wind resistance compared to Owens Corning’s Duration shingles. Choose Malarkey for harsher climates.
What are the customer reviews saying about Malarkey shingles versus Owens Corning shingles?
Customer reviews indicate Malarkey shingles are praised for their durability and eco-friendliness, while Owens Corning shingles are commended for their variety and warranty options. Consider Malarkey for sustainable projects and Owens Corning for diverse selections and robust warranty coverage.
Are there any significant cost differences between Malarkey and Owens Corning shingles?
Yes, cost differences exist. Malarkey shingles typically range from $90 to $110 per square, while Owens Corning shingles range from $85 to $130 per square. For budget considerations, compare local pricing and consider installation costs, as they may vary based on shingle choice and roofing contractor.
